Comments on: Why I don’t do Word Counts http://booksbywomen.org/why-i-don-t-do-word-counts-by-cath-staincliffe/ Wed, 23 Mar 2016 11:18:36 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.5.3 By: Cath Staincliffe http://booksbywomen.org/why-i-don-t-do-word-counts-by-cath-staincliffe/#comment-47337 Wed, 23 Mar 2016 11:18:36 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=10568#comment-47337 In reply to Evie Gaughan.

Glad I’m not the only one, Evie! It’s still an issue for me and I’m green with envy when other writers I know talk about having to cut 30,000 words because their book’s too long. I know what you mean about books feeling ‘padded out’ and as a reader I do get tried of books that seem longer than the story or writing warrants. Maybe one day the trend will change but no sign of that yet. Good luck with your writing.

]]>
By: Evie Gaughan http://booksbywomen.org/why-i-don-t-do-word-counts-by-cath-staincliffe/#comment-47336 Wed, 23 Mar 2016 10:52:01 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=10568#comment-47336 Well this article has really cheered me up! My novels always seem to hover around the 60,000 word mark – which isn’t too much of a problem when you’re self-published, but I have had some feedback from readers saying they wished the story had been longer. However, as a reader myself, I can always sense when a writer has been ‘advised’ by their publisher to increase the wordcount and find myself getting frustrated with being led up the garden path! Just writing for the sake of length seems a bit counter-intuitive to me, but I guess if there’s a book deal on the line, I’d find the words somewhere! I’m not sure a traditional publisher would even consider a commercial fiction book of less than 80,000 words, especially women’s fiction (which is a whole other conversation!) Great article – thanks for sharing 🙂

]]>
By: Cath Staincliffe http://booksbywomen.org/why-i-don-t-do-word-counts-by-cath-staincliffe/#comment-46927 Sun, 29 Nov 2015 10:46:33 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=10568#comment-46927 In reply to Kirtida Gautam.

Hi Kirtida,
Thanks for getting in touch. It sounds like you are the opposite to me! That does seem long, I think most books are 80K to 100K (though lots are shorter or longer). If your novel naturally breaks into two parts then you could think about treating it as two books. But if it would spoil it to split it up then you might need to consider editing it into a more manageable length. Good luck.

]]>
By: Kirtida Gautam http://booksbywomen.org/why-i-don-t-do-word-counts-by-cath-staincliffe/#comment-46923 Sat, 28 Nov 2015 10:25:12 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=10568#comment-46923 Hi Cath,

Thanks for sharing this experience. My problem as an author is that I end up writing long- really long books. My word counts go 1.9K+ Is it okay to write long novels or they are again considered ill-fitted by industry standards? As a matter of fact, I plan to break my novel in 2 parts before sending it to agents because I am scared that a very long novel might not go well with agents as I am a first time writer.

Can you please advice me on this matter?

]]>
By: Cath Staincliffe http://booksbywomen.org/why-i-don-t-do-word-counts-by-cath-staincliffe/#comment-46442 Fri, 26 Jun 2015 08:50:02 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=10568#comment-46442 In reply to Amy Impellizzeri.

Hello Amy, I’m very glad it’s helped. Writing is tough enough without following rules that make it harder. Good luck.

]]>
By: Cath Staincliffe http://booksbywomen.org/why-i-don-t-do-word-counts-by-cath-staincliffe/#comment-46441 Fri, 26 Jun 2015 08:48:46 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=10568#comment-46441 In reply to Whitney Dineen.

Hi, Whitney, Thanks for getting in touch. There’s so many ways to write and finding what works is the key, I think. Sounds like you have. Happy writing.

]]>
By: Amy Impellizzeri http://booksbywomen.org/why-i-don-t-do-word-counts-by-cath-staincliffe/#comment-46438 Thu, 25 Jun 2015 18:23:32 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=10568#comment-46438 I found this so interesting. Thank you for your insight. I’m a slave to word counts even though I hate them. My best days of writing (and not coincidentally, the most productive) are the days I throw word counts out the window and just write the scene that’s been brewing in my brain for days … This is some great advice and I’ll be sharing! Thank you!

]]>
By: Whitney Dineen http://booksbywomen.org/why-i-don-t-do-word-counts-by-cath-staincliffe/#comment-46437 Thu, 25 Jun 2015 15:04:59 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=10568#comment-46437 Hello, Soul Sista! So glad to know there are others out there that don’t freak over a daily goal. The story finds it’s own way out when you give it the lead.

]]>
By: Cath http://booksbywomen.org/why-i-don-t-do-word-counts-by-cath-staincliffe/#comment-44216 Fri, 20 Feb 2015 08:51:46 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=10568#comment-44216 In reply to D. Ellis Phleps.

Thanks very much for your comment. I like the way you’ve phrased it – I can tell you are a poet. All the very best with your work. Cath

]]>
By: D. Ellis Phleps http://booksbywomen.org/why-i-don-t-do-word-counts-by-cath-staincliffe/#comment-43819 Wed, 18 Feb 2015 19:20:40 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=10568#comment-43819 I’m happy to read you here and I thank you for this thoughtful piece.

Two things sang out:

I am also a “writer who writes sparingly.” My recently completed and first full-length book of ecstatic poetry is full of space, many lines only one word. It takes a certain courage to trust the reader this much.

And, I agree that “a difficult or emotionally loaded [subject]… demands the old pen and paper.” Immediacy of paper and pen, eyes following this lead of ink, sound of pages turning, the rocker in which I sit or some place in the sun…all grounding me in my body, on the planet, giving tether to the mind, wanting to wander at will.

]]>