Comments on: Are You a Real Writer? https://booksbywomen.org/are-you-a-real-writer/ Sun, 07 Aug 2016 11:16:00 +0000 hourly 1 https://wordpress.org/?v=6.5.3 By: Sarah Banham https://booksbywomen.org/are-you-a-real-writer/#comment-47821 Sun, 07 Aug 2016 11:16:00 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=11288#comment-47821 Putting others down is a nasty trait in some. That kind of confidence-killing is not acceptable in any of the writing-related groups I’m attached to.

A few years ago, I met up with another author who challenged my work. She suggested my (then) 28 years’ experience and (then) 7 books was not enough to write a book helping others write a book and, thus, stripped my confidence.

Of course I told her I felt it was enough and we parted ways. I did discover she had adopted this attitude with others too.

Comfidence takes time to achieve so anyone stripping you of it should be stopped instantly.

Great article btw. ♡

]]>
By: Inspiration to Open Your Heart and Some Focus - Kira Elliott https://booksbywomen.org/are-you-a-real-writer/#comment-46291 Thu, 28 May 2015 22:47:45 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=11288#comment-46291 […] Are You A Real Writer?  by Mary Rowen -Mary explains how participating in a writing group helped her own being a writer and moved her beyond her journals. Being in a writing group for many years myself helped build my confidence and ownership of being a writer. One of the future projects I have in mind is to start an online writing group. If you are not in a group or have never been in one, I highly recommend finding one or starting one as Mary did. […]

]]>
By: Madeleine D'Esye https://booksbywomen.org/are-you-a-real-writer/#comment-42445 Sat, 31 Jan 2015 00:09:51 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=11288#comment-42445 In reply to A.D. Norton.

Excellent point A.D! I have only started to feel like a “real writer” when I began to take it seriously, like a part time job. And yes, I’m unpublished. At this moment.

]]>
By: Mary Rowen https://booksbywomen.org/are-you-a-real-writer/#comment-17676 Sun, 08 Jun 2014 16:44:58 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=11288#comment-17676 In reply to A.D. Norton.

Thank you for the comment, A.D. I agree with what you say about serious writers. They come in many varieties. As for writing groups, I’ve been super lucky with the ones I’ve joined. However, I understand the frustration of a group that doesn’t click. At one point in my post-college life, I took an evening writing class in a continuing ed. program, and the people in the class decided to form a writing group. We met twice, I think, but did it in a restaurant/bar, and it was a large group, and nothing ever really got accomplished. After those two meetings, I didn’t go back, and I sort of forgot about the whole thing until now. I wonder if you could find a good online writing group through SheWrites? There are lots of people on there, writing at many different levels and on different topics. Best of luck. I do think a good group is really, really helpful

]]>
By: A.D. Norton https://booksbywomen.org/are-you-a-real-writer/#comment-17658 Sat, 07 Jun 2014 21:33:10 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=11288#comment-17658 In reply to A.D. Norton.

Excuse the typos this was typed on my iPhone

]]>
By: A.D. Norton https://booksbywomen.org/are-you-a-real-writer/#comment-17657 Sat, 07 Jun 2014 21:31:30 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=11288#comment-17657 I always try to be encouraging to fellow writers and fellow aspiring writers it’s who I am, I’ve taught writing to undergrads & it’s just part of my nature. I’ve run into situations where someone aspiring to be a writer I helped and they turned around and every chance they got they would try to knock me down or get me to give them editors names etc. This is another woman too which was really kind of shocking to me but I helped as much as I could and then just moved on… but it’s funny because dhe brought up that question about she considered herself a “real” writer (she had no credits) and another woman that she knew who wrote for TV she said was NOT a real writer! I just think this is a really touchy issue. Because my opinion is that if you’re serious about writing you’re a real writer and by serious I mean that you seriously work at it and then you try to get your work published. Lots of successful writers and screenwriters spend years or they go through phases where they don’t create. I’ve also had very good and very bad experiences in writers groups. Including graduate school. I’d love to find a quality online writers group. I am always trying to see the best in people, some people are the opposite (& I wonder why they all seem to live in LA!)

]]>
By: Mary Rowen https://booksbywomen.org/are-you-a-real-writer/#comment-17275 Fri, 09 May 2014 15:14:57 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=11288#comment-17275 In reply to Linda Strader.

That’s one of the best things about writing groups, I think. There’s that delicate balance between encouraging each other but also letting someone know when something isn’t working. And like you say, you, as the writer, don’t need to agree with the comments, but it gives you something to think about. Since one of my writing groups has five members, I’m usually more likely to change something I really like if two or three people say it’s not working. But every case is different. I’m just so thankful for all of them. Thank you for your comment, Linda!

]]>
By: Linda Strader https://booksbywomen.org/are-you-a-real-writer/#comment-17274 Fri, 09 May 2014 15:07:57 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=11288#comment-17274 I’ve belonged to a writers forum for over a year. They’ve been wonderful! It’s not all about telling me my work is good – they will also tell me when it needs work. Although I don’t always agree with recommended changes, I take every suggestion to heart and think about it carefully, then it’s ultimately up to me what to do.

]]>
By: Mary Rowen https://booksbywomen.org/are-you-a-real-writer/#comment-17238 Fri, 02 May 2014 00:52:08 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=11288#comment-17238 In reply to Julie Brown.

Wow, Julie, I think you’re right on the money with that last point. When you can confidently tell people what you write, then you’re a writer. Perfect.

Congratulations on your writing career as well. And how cool is it that someone in your writing group helped you find a publisher? This is a wonderful story and I wish you much continued success!

]]>
By: Julie Brown https://booksbywomen.org/are-you-a-real-writer/#comment-17237 Thu, 01 May 2014 22:43:32 +0000 http://booksbywomenorg.netfirms.com/?p=11288#comment-17237 I received a great deal of encouragement and help from my writing/critique group. They helped me to view myself as a writer and to treat writing as my job, not just a hobby. Many people came and went over the years, but about 8 of us regulars are still together. It was somebody in my writing group that led me to a publisher who took my manuscript and helped me accomplish one of my biggest dreams – to become a (fairy princess – oh wait, that’s not it…) published author!
As for when you can call yourself a write, I say it’s when you have a confident answer to the inevitable question, “What do you write?” Does not matter what the answer is as long as you are proud to announce it!
Best of luck to you all!

]]>